Home › Sell your records › Brooklyn, NY
Where to sell vinyl records in Brooklyn
14 shops in Brooklyn, New York buy used records — 14 confirmed by their own website or customers' reviews. Expect roughly 30–50% of resale value in cash, more in store credit; call ahead for large collections (many shops make house calls for 500+ records).
Human Head Records
4.8 ★★★★★ 483 reviews
Record shop with a large collection of new & used vinyl, plus turntables & other audio equipment.
Academy Record Annex
4.7 ★★★★★ 337 reviews
Browser-friendly new & used music store featuring LPs & CDs in a range of genres.
Vinyl Fantasy
4.6 ★★★★★ 242 reviews
Cozy storefront record shop offering an eclectic mix of new & used LPs, plus comics & funky art.
Second Hand Records NYC
4.9 ★★★★★ 213 reviews
Secondhand shop featuring new and used LPs of all genres, plus listening stations and a comfy couch.
Superior Elevation Record Store / SE DJ SCHOOL
4.8 ★★★★★ 199 reviews
Friendly option with a wide selection of records, as well as listening stations and DJ courses.
Record Shop
4.9 ★★★★★ 172 reviews
Store buying and selling used records, including reggae and soul offerings, in an environment with a cool vibe.
Psychic Records
4.6 ★★★★★ 167 reviews
Store offering new & used CDs & cassettes plus new LPs, with instrument cables & accessories, too.
Black Gold Records
4.6 ★★★★★ 161 reviews
This cozy shop with a vintage vibe offers records across a variety of genres plus coffee & antiques.
Fifth Avenue Record Shop
4 ★★★★☆ 116 reviews
Snug, longstanding music shop selling used vinyl, CDs, cassettes & stereo components since 1972.
Getting the best price in Brooklyn
- Look up your valuable titles first. Check sold prices on Discogs for your exact pressings — a shop prices a mystery box conservatively, but will pay real money for titles they can see are worth it. Our selling guide covers how to spot the valuable 10%.
- Get offers from more than one shop. Human Head Records and Academy Record Annex may specialize in different genres — the same box can get very different offers.
- Ask for the store-credit price too. It typically runs 20–30% higher than cash if you'd spend it anyway.
- Don't clean records with household products before selling — dealers prefer honest dust to swirl marks. Grading matters: see how grading works.