HomeNew YorkBrooklyn › Brooklyn Record Exchange

Brooklyn Record Exchange

4.9 ★★★★★ 68 Google reviews · Record store

Buys records listening stations

Visit

87 Guernsey St
Brooklyn, NY 11222

+1 347-294-4449

Directions Website

Instagram · Shop online

Hours

Monday 12–8 pm
Tuesday 12–8 pm
Wednesday 12–8 pm
Thursday 12–8 pm
Friday 12–8 pm
Saturday 12–8 pm
Sunday 12–8 pm

Where to find Brooklyn Record Exchange

What collectors say again and again

The things reviewers keep bringing up across 68 Google reviews — in their own words.

🎧 listening stations 3 mentions

“There are listening stations available, and Mitchell was of great help in finding things I was looking for.”

What customers say

Great shop with good prices. The clerk was super friendly, knowledgeable, and actually wanted to talk about music, which I love. Its great to be in a space where people are excited about music.

★★★★★ — Emily, 2022-11

Really great shop. Friendly staff, great selection, and reasonable pricing! A really great spot to browse and find new favorites and old friends.

★★★★★ — Julie, 2025-07

Great place for used records! I walked out with 13 LPs the first time I visited here. Now I visit this place every time I’m in Brooklyn. This store may be smaller in size compared to other places in Brooklyn, but I found more hidden gems here. Well-procured selections in multiple genres.

★★★★★ — Stephen, 2025-11

Great shop design. More alternative tunes but also a good electronic/house section (new and second hand stuff). What really stands out is the fact that the records are all really clean and well sorted. Welcoming staff who answers all your questions. I highly recommend!

★★★★★ — Michael, 2024-04

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 68 reviews →

Record stores near Brooklyn Record Exchange

Dream Fishing Tackle

4 ★★★★☆ 138 reviews

59 Norman Ave, Brooklyn, NY

punkhip-hop

Fishing-supply center stocking bait & tackle plus rods, reels & equipment from popular brands.

under a mile away

Music Planet GAMES AND RECORDS

4.7 ★★★★★ 143 reviews

649 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY

metalCDs too

Vinyl shop, with a selection of new and used releases, plus CDs and DVDs.

under a mile away

Captured Record Shop

4.5 ★★★★★ 189 reviews

718 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY

cassettesCDs too

Small record store tucked in a basement location specializing in new & used vinyl & cassettes.

under a mile away

All record stores in Brooklyn, NY →

Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this shop? Claim your listing — it's free.