HomeNew YorkBrooklyn › Fifth Avenue Record Shop

Fifth Avenue Record Shop

4 ★★★★☆ 116 Google reviews · Record store · Music store

Buys records jazz cassettes

Snug, longstanding music shop selling used vinyl, CDs, cassettes & stereo components since 1972.

Visit

439 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215

(347) 335-0881

Directions

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 1–7 PM
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 4–7 PM
Friday 2:30–7 PM
Saturday 3–8 PM
Sunday 11 AM–6 PM

Where to find Fifth Avenue Record Shop

What's in the crates

The genres crate-diggers actually call out in reviews of Fifth Avenue Record Shop — not self-reported, earned.

🎷 jazz 2 mentions

“He's very house music friendly, but also has a lot of classic rock, jazz, r&b & rap vinyl.”

All shops known for jazz →

What collectors say again and again

The things reviewers keep bringing up across 116 Google reviews — in their own words.

📼 cassettes 3 mentions

“I didn’t know what I wanted but found myself leaving with 7 cassette tapes that I am so excited about.”

What customers say

The place that let the music reign. A must for locals, travelers and time lords. Epic selection and clutch deals. Impossible finds, inquisitive conversations and the beta tape you’ve been hunting for. The choicest in election, the beats of beats. You must and find your reality in vinyl form.

★★★★★ — Kort, 2019-10

just touching base hoping all is well and you get back to reg hours soon,hey i was there like you said till four but you never showed will you be open thursday march 20th,you sti,no return calls

★★★★★ — Dominick, 2025-04

I'm in love with this place. I spent as much time in there as I would in a bookstore. The owner was helpful and friendly. People don't care for the smell there but I like it. It has a vintage smell and look. There's sooo much to look through that I have to go back there and add more to my record collection.

★★★★★ — Allie, 2016-11

The best neighborhood spot, my first friendly face in the neighborhood. Can’t say enough great things, such a vibe!!! Found this place after walking by hearing tunes coming out the window. I spotted the dj deck and had to immediately turn around and run inside with my friend. So glad I did!

★★★★★ — Madeline, 2024-10

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 116 reviews →

Record stores near Fifth Avenue Record Shop

Psychic Records

4.6 ★★★★★ 167 reviews

413B 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY

Buys records cassettes

Store offering new & used CDs & cassettes plus new LPs, with instrument cables & accessories, too.

under a mile away

Sterling Records

4.6 ★★★★★ 36 reviews

121 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY

soul & funklistening stationsposters & merch

under a mile away

Black Gold Records

4.6 ★★★★★ 161 reviews

461 Court St, Brooklyn, NY

Buys records dollar binscoffee or bar

This cozy shop with a vintage vibe offers records across a variety of genres plus coffee & antiques.

under a mile away

All record stores in Brooklyn, NY →

Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this shop? Claim your listing — it's free.