Home › Sell your records › Indianapolis, IN
Where to sell vinyl records in Indianapolis
7 shops in Indianapolis, Indiana buy used records — 5 confirmed by their own website or customers' reviews. Expect roughly 30–50% of resale value in cash, more in store credit; call ahead for large collections (many shops make house calls for 500+ records).
The Exchange
4.6 ★★★★★ 869 reviews
Retail chain for new & used CDs & vinyl, plus movies, games & related collectibles.
Indy CD & Vinyl
4.7 ★★★★★ 808 reviews
Long-running, independent outfit selling new-release & secondhand recordings in roomy surrounds.
Square Cat Vinyl
4.7 ★★★★★ 740 reviews
Hip, industrial-chic shop offering new & used records, plus live shows, coffee, wine & beer.
Luna Music
4.8 ★★★★★ 480 reviews
Vinyl and CD store stocking new and used titles, along with cassettes, T-shirts, socks and stickers.
Irvington Vinyl & Books
4.8 ★★★★★ 470 reviews
Traditional new & secondhand book & record store specializing in titles from smaller publishers.
The Exchange
4.6 ★★★★★ 401 reviews
Retail chain for new & used CDs & vinyl, plus movies, games & related collectibles.
Getting the best price in Indianapolis
- Look up your valuable titles first. Check sold prices on Discogs for your exact pressings — a shop prices a mystery box conservatively, but will pay real money for titles they can see are worth it. Our selling guide covers how to spot the valuable 10%.
- Get offers from more than one shop. The Exchange and Indy CD & Vinyl may specialize in different genres — the same box can get very different offers.
- Ask for the store-credit price too. It typically runs 20–30% higher than cash if you'd spend it anyway.
- Don't clean records with household products before selling — dealers prefer honest dust to swirl marks. Grading matters: see how grading works.