Record Stores in Indianapolis, IN
Indianapolis has 10 record stores in this directory, including 7 that buy used records. Listings are ranked by local reputation — rating weighted by review count — and refreshed from public map data.
Karma Records
4.7 ★★★★★ 1,093 reviews
Vintage shop selling vinyl albums (new and used), CDs and cassettes plus rock-star T-shirts and incense.
The Exchange
4.6 ★★★★★ 869 reviews
Retail chain for new & used CDs & vinyl, plus movies, games & related collectibles.
Indy CD & Vinyl
4.7 ★★★★★ 808 reviews
Long-running, independent outfit selling new-release & secondhand recordings in roomy surrounds.
Square Cat Vinyl
4.7 ★★★★★ 740 reviews
Hip, industrial-chic shop offering new & used records, plus live shows, coffee, wine & beer.
Luna Music
4.8 ★★★★★ 480 reviews
Vinyl and CD store stocking new and used titles, along with cassettes, T-shirts, socks and stickers.
Irvington Vinyl & Books
4.8 ★★★★★ 470 reviews
Traditional new & secondhand book & record store specializing in titles from smaller publishers.
The Exchange
4.6 ★★★★★ 401 reviews
Retail chain for new & used CDs & vinyl, plus movies, games & related collectibles.
Karma Records
4.6 ★★★★★ 207 reviews
Metal records alongside soundtracks, cassettes and CDs sold here.
Where to sell vinyl records in Indianapolis
These Indianapolis shops indicate they buy used records. Call ahead for big collections — most stores pay more for clean copies of titles they can resell.
- The Exchange — 5909 E 82nd St
- Indy CD & Vinyl — 806 Broad Ripple Ave
- Square Cat Vinyl — 1054 Virginia Ave
- Luna Music — 5202 N College Ave
- Irvington Vinyl & Books — 202 S Audubon Rd
- The Exchange — 10019 E Washington St
- Take Care Records — 6215 Allisonville Rd