Home › New York › Commack › Mr Cheapo CDs & Records

Mr Cheapo CDs & Records

4.6 ★★★★★ 227 Google reviews · Record store · CD store · Video game store

Buys records ✓ (per their site) blues cassettesCDs tooposters & merchbooks & movies

Friendly staff for a sprawling shop offering new and used CDs and vinyl records, plus DVDs and VHS tapes.

Visit

2020 Jericho Tpke #46
Commack, NY 11725

☎ (631) 543-8686

Directions Website

Instagram · Facebook

Hours

Monday	10:30 AM–7 PM
Tuesday	10:30 AM–7 PM
Wednesday	10:30 AM–7 PM
Thursday	10:30 AM–7 PM
Friday	10:30 AM–7:30 PM
Saturday	10:30 AM–7:30 PM
Sunday	10:30 AM–6 PM

Where to find Mr Cheapo CDs & Records

What's in the crates

The genres crate-diggers actually call out in reviews of Mr Cheapo CDs & Records — not self-reported, earned.

🎺 blues 2 mentions

All shops known for blues →

What collectors say again and again

The things reviewers keep bringing up across 227 Google reviews — in their own words.

 📼 cassettes 8 mentions 
“I frequently visit to find CDs and tapes to add to my collection.”
 💽 CDs too 8 mentions 
“Amazing entertainment store full of Records, Cds, DVDs, Funko Pops and various other memorabilia.”
 🖼️ posters & merch 2 mentions 
“Amazing entertainment store full of Records, Cds, DVDs, Funko Pops and various other memorabilia.”
 📚 books & movies 4 mentions 
“Amazing entertainment store full of Records, Cds, DVDs, Funko Pops and various other memorabilia.”

What customers say

Amazing entertainment store full of Records, Cds, DVDs, Funko Pops and various other memorabilia. Great prices and the owner is a great guy with over 30 years in the business. Definitely worth the visit.

★★★★★ — Saadi, 2023-03

Great place! I frequently visit to find CDs and tapes to add to my collection. They also sell some music hardware, and various records, VHS tapes, DVDs, etc. Prices are always pretty fair and I can always find at least something I want, since their selection is massive.

★★★★★ — Machine, 2021-10

Had so much fun browsing and picking out all my old favorites. Staff was helpful, selection was broad, prices were great. Throwing away all my old CDs in the 2010s was a huge mistake. I’m happy to actually own music again and grateful to have this store nearby!

★★★★★ — Megan, 2025-08

I love this place, the staff is extremely helpful and friendly and there are tons of records and retro gaming in store. I was able to buy a PS2 console a few weeks ago and it was so clean. This is a must go for the area.

★★★★★ — Daniel, 2023-03

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 227 reviews →